LNP Inertia Continues

In a surprise outcome the LNP maintained leadership over the weekend noting that it remains unknown whether or not the LNP will form a majority government. Energy and climate were at the heart of this election with Labor putting forward material initiatives that would increase investment in renewable energy generation (increased funding to the CEFC) and reduce emissions through the extension of the safeguard mechanism, amongst a number of other initiatives. The LNP are less ambitious and maintain the emissions reduction target of 26-28% below 2005 levels by 2030. The LNP will extend the Climate Solutions Fund by providing additional funding to the Emissions Reduction Fund which is the reverse auction of ACCU’s managed by the Clean Energy Regulator.

In terms of energy generation and transmission the LNP has pledged support for Snowy Hydro 2.0, the Underwriting New Generation Investment program and Marinus Link (Interconnector between TAS and VIC, part of the Battery of the Nation plan).

The futures markets (energy and environmental certificates) had priced in a Labor victory. The result over the weekend may put upward pressure on forward prices (energy & Enviro) as there will be less new renewable generation invested in over the coming years. That being said, state based renewable energy targets remain in place as per the following:

QLD – 50% Renewable by 2030

NSW – No target

VIC – 25% by 2020 and 40% by 2025

SA – No target

Tas – 100% by 2022

The larger demand states are QLD, NSW and VIC who are still heavily reliant on coal powered generation. NSW is the only state of these three whereby there is no target. Given that QLD and VICs renewable energy targets remain in place there should not be a material decline in new renewable generation development in these regions. For NSW, at least for the time being, new renewable generation will be a function of price. Currently NSW prices are at a level whereby a solar or wind developer should be able to secure funding and a PPA.

If you would like to know more about the potential impact that our LNP government may have on Australian energy prices, please contact Edge Energy Services on 07 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.

Queensland spot prices – March vs April to date

In Queensland, we have observed lower daytime spot prices since the beginning of April, relative to March averages.

Taking a closer look at half hourly average spot prices seen so far in April, we can see that between 8am and 4pm spot prices have been softer than the same periods in March. Following this, spot prices are higher in the evening peak periods. Whilst it is a very small data set, this is the relationship that many in the market expect to evolve.

Softer spot prices in the day will motivate generators to price more aggressively (price higher) in the evening peak to increase earnings which have been lost during the day.

Should we see this evolution of softer spot prices during the sunlight hours of the day, it will put further strain on the Queensland solar industry which has had several setbacks of late.

In addition, we can observe from the below graph that there has been an increase in generation from utility scale solar, in terms of both peak and average generation. The increase in solar is making more low-cost generation available in Queensland. New generation from these solar plants remains insufficient to meet all demand and therefore, solar is not setting prices.

If you have any questions regarding spot prices or any other matter relating to energy, please contact Edge Energy Services on 07 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.

Clean Energy Regulator confirms 2019 RRP and STP

On 12 March 2019, the Clean Energy Regulator (CER) has confirmed the 2019 renewable power percentage (RPP) and small-scale technology percentage (STP) has been set by legislative amendment.

The 2019 RRP has been set at 18.6% and the 2019 STP has been set at 21.73%.

As explained by the CER, the RRP and STP set the annual statutory demand for large-scale generation certificates and small-scale technology certificates in the Renewable Energy Target.

If you have any questions regarding the 2019 RRP or STP or any other matter relating to energy, please contact Edge Energy Services on 07 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.

AEMO releases draft Marginal Loss Factors

The Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO) released its draft marginal loss factors (MLFs) today. As generally expected, solar and wind farms that are a long distance from the regional reference point have been hurt.

The most notable example of this is the Broken Hill solar farm, which has a draft MLF for FY20 of 0.7254. This is 0.2535 below the current MLF. If the draft MLF is confirmed in the final report (due 1 April 2019), this will reduce the volume of electricity sold by the solar farm by 25%.

A number of other solar and wind farms had material reductions in MLF and are facing a challenging situation. Most notably, Silverton Wind Farm (NSW), Karadoc Solar Farm (VIC), Griffith Solar Farm (NSW) and Parkes Solar Farm (NSW).

MLFs are very difficult to estimate, which is reflected in the relatively large change we are observing year on year. Amongst many other concerns, this creates uncertainty for the investment community.

If you have any questions regarding the draft MLFs or any other matter relating to energy, please contact Edge Energy Services on 07 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.

CleanCo Moving Ahead – Part 2

With expectations that CleanCo will be trading in the NEM by mid this year, things are getting into full swing. Last week CleanCo appointed its first two key executives – Miles George and Geoff Dutaillis.

Who are these new executives?

Miles George has been appointed the Interim Chief Executive Officer (CEO) at CleanCo. His role at CleanCo is to secure cleaner, more affordable, sustainable energy and secure supply of electricity for Queensland (QLD). He was previously the CEO and Managing Director of Infigen Energy. After leaving Infigen Energy in 2016, Miles continued as a strategic adviser until December 2017. During and after his time at Infigen, Miles has been the Chairman of the Clean Energy Council, a representative on the AEMC Reliability panel, an Expert panel member for AEMO and Director of the Australian Conservation Foundation.

Geoff Dutaillis has been appointed the General Manager of Transition. Geoff was most recently the CEO (Australia) of Wind Energy Holdings, a leading renewable energy company based in Thailand. The company has interest in various Australian wind farms. Geoff has also held executive positions at Infigen Energy as Chief Operating Officer (COO) from 2009 until 2013 and Lendlease more recently as Head of Sustainability.

 What is the mandate for CleanCo?

CleanCo has the mandate to increase competition in the electricity market at peak times of demand when prices are generally at their highest. CleanCo is expected to transform intermittent renewable generation into firm financial products for customers and retailers while backing QLD’s renewable energy and low emissions generators.

 Which of the existing generators are to be transferred from the current government owned corporations; Stanwell and CS Energy?

Initially, CleanCo’s portfolio will include a range of existing renewable and low emission energy generation assets including:

  1. Wivenhoe pump storage hydro plant,
  2. Swanbank E gas-fired power station, and
  3. Barron Gorge, Kareeya and Koombooloomba hydro power stations.

If you have any questions regarding CleanCo or any other matter relating to energy, please contact Edge Energy Services on 07 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.

Update from COAG Energy Council meeting

The COAG Energy Council met today for their 21st meeting. On the agenda was AEMO addressing their work in preparing the grid for summer, bringing down electricity costs and ensuring long term grid reliability and security.

AEMO highlighted the priority of work being undertaken to ensure that there is enough dispatchable generation in the NEM and integration of renewable and distributed energy resources. The Ministers agreed to a work program for the ESB to develop advice on a long term, fit for purpose market framework to support reliability that could apply from the mid-2020s. There was very little detail on this framework, however Edge will look to discover more.

Reliability

Ministers agreed to the final draft bill which gives effect to the Retail Reliability Obligation. The final package of rules will be brought to Council for approval in the first half of 2019, with a target commencement date of 1 July 2019.

Transmission upgrades

Ministers agreed on an approach to deliver the Group 1 transmission network projects. Group 1 projects include:

• Increasing transfer capacity between New South Wales, Queensland, and Victoria by 170-460 MW;

• Reducing congestion for existing and committed renewable energy developments in western and north-western Victoria; and

• Remedy system strength in South Australia.

In the Base plan, these initial transmission developments for Group 1 are costed at between $450 million and $650 million, and the assets will continue to benefit consumers well beyond the 20-year ISP forecast period. More cost benefit analysis work is to be conducted on Group 2 and 3 projects.

If you have any questions regarding this article or the electricity market in general, call Edge on 07 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.

A lesson from RCR Tomlinson: corporate PPA’s and the sharing of risk

RCR Tomlinson entering voluntary administration this week has been a major eye-opener in the renewable energy world. The engineering firm had shown signs of stress earlier in the year, particularly when it was forced to record a $57 million write-down on the value of it’s Daydream and Hayman solar farms in Queensland. Following this, the company successfully went to market and raised an additional $100 million in capital. Now after incurring liquidated damages as a result of running late on solar projects, directors had no choice but to put the company into administration.

In the renewable energy space, these events particularly emphasise the potential risk of entering into a PPA with a project that requires development prior to receiving any MWh. For those considering entering into a renewable PPA, it is imperative to be mindful of the gravity of the project risk taken with these developments. With increasingly stringent connection criteria being enforced by AEMO and transmission companies, corporate PPA off-takers need to consider the structuring of risk in the PPA to avoid being exposed in situations like this.

There are several ways to manage project risk through legal and commercial arrangements. Without being privy to the details of RCR Tomlinson’s contracts, it would appear that the company was wearing “connection to the grid” risk. On face value, this would have felt like a win to the off-taker. However, the off-takers are now in a position where the risk has fallen onto them due the collapse of the company. Whilst RCR Tomlinson shouldn’t have taken that risk, the PPA counterparties arguably also should not have turned a blind eye to the potential project risk.

This is an important lesson for any corporate entity looking to enter into a PPA, by understanding whether your developer and construction partners have the appropriate means to manage the risk that is placed on them. Having liquidated damages in a contract is essential. However, be mindful that at the end of the day, if a company is placed into administration and subsequently liquidated, liquidated damages are worthless.

CleanCo moving ahead

In a media statement released 30 August, the Queensland Government confirmed their intention to establish CleanCo, Queensland’s third publicly owned electricity generator. CleanCo will have a strategic portfolio of low and no emission power generations assets, and will build, own and operate new renewable generation. It is understood that CleanCo will take control of assets including Wivenhoe, Barron Gorge and Kareeya hydro power stations and the Swanbank E gas power station, courtesy of a restructure of the two current publicly-owned electricity generators – CS Energy and Stanwell Corporation. CleanCo is expected to be trading by mid-2019.

Additional Small Scale Solar Coming to Victoria

The Victorian Government has announced that it will offer half priced solar panels to 650,000 households over the next 10 years.

This scheme, known as The Solar Home scheme, is currently valued at $1.24 billion and is open to owner-occupied homes with:

  • A combined household income of less than $180,000 per year; and
  • A home value of up to $3 million.

Households who are unable to install solar panels can instead choose to get a $1,000 rebate by changing their current hot water system to a solar hot water system. The solar hot water rebate is open to up to 60,000 homes.

How will this impact the market?

2017 had the highest rate of installation of rooftop solar and 2018 is on track to break this record. The additional demand created by the Victorian scheme could increase the number of certificates, and therefore the obligation for retailers to purchase certificates. This cost is likely to be passed through to consumers. In the short term, it could put downwards pressure on the certificate prices, however any reduction will be short lived as the Clean Energy Regulator adjusts the surrender target, matching demand with supply.

If you would like to understand how this may impact your portfolio please contact Edge on (07) 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.

Price of Utility Scale Solar Being Questioned

The engineering company, RCR Tomlinson, went into trading halt on July 30, 2018 and its CEO, Paul Dalgleish, has stepped down. The trading halt is due to an investigation into cost blowouts for unspecified projects, which will hurt the FY18 annual profit.

The deputy state secretary of the Queensland and NT Electrical Trades Union, Peter Ong, has stated that RCR has been undercutting other bids by as much as $30 million when bidding for utility scale solar project. Peter Ong’s major concern is the use of cheaper labour to try and make up the difference.

For the broader market, if RCR have been under-pricing the engineering cost of installing utility scale solar, there could be an increase in the expected price of new utility scale solar. Citigroup warned that the recent solar farm built for Sun Metals may have had a cost blowout by as much as $7 million.

RCR has not confirmed that it is the utility scale solar which has led to the cost increase.

If you would like to understand how this may impact your portfolio please contact Edge on (07) 3905 9220 or 1800 334 336.